Best Xbox Games to Collect

Ranked from 54 analysed games · updated hourly£$€

These lists are built from MyPlayersVault’s own analyses of Xbox games — Vault Score, collector demand, market movement and current new and used prices — not from opinion. Every game links to its full price guide.

Top picks

£$€

The highest Vault Scores — our 0–100 rating of collector demand, scarcity and market strength.

1OutRun 2006 Coast 2 CoastRacing56North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£507USED£203DEMANDNicheAnalysed 8 Aug 20262Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach VolleyballSports56North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£187USED£45DEMANDNicheAnalysed 4 Sept 20263Shenmue IIAction & Adventure55North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£29USED£11DEMANDEmergingAnalysed 23 Oct 20264Silent Hill 2Action & Adventure52UK / PALHIGH-ALPHANEW£131USED£66DEMANDEstablishedAnalysed 6 Nov 20265Metal Slug 3Action & Adventure52UK / PALHIGH-ALPHANEW£21USED£15DEMANDNicheAnalysed 26 Jun 20266Time Splitters 2FPS49North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£50USED£13DEMANDNicheAnalysed 5 Aug 20267The WarriorsAction & Adventure48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£164USED£41DEMANDNicheAnalysed 2 Nov 20268Def Jam Fight for NYWrestling48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£152USED£96DEMANDNicheAnalysed 5 Aug 20269Silent Hill 4: The RoomHorror48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£131USED£62DEMANDNicheAnalysed 9 Aug 202610Red Dead Revolver2004 · Action & Adventure48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£82USED£13DEMANDNicheAnalysed 26 May 2026

Most valuable

£$€

The Xbox games with the highest current values.

1OutRun 2006 Coast 2 CoastRacing56North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£507USED£203DEMANDNicheAnalysed 8 Aug 20262Dead or Alive Xtreme Beach VolleyballSports56North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£187USED£45DEMANDNicheAnalysed 4 Sept 20263The WarriorsAction & Adventure48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£164USED£41DEMANDNicheAnalysed 2 Nov 20264Halo 22004 · FPS32North America (NTSC-U)MID-ALPHANEW£154USED£11DEMANDEstablishedAnalysed 21 Aug 20265Def Jam Fight for NYWrestling48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£152USED£96DEMANDNicheAnalysed 5 Aug 20266The Simpsons Hit and RunAction & Adventure38North America (NTSC-U)MID-ALPHANEW£139USED£48DEMANDNicheAnalysed 2 Oct 20267Silent Hill 2Action & Adventure52UK / PALHIGH-ALPHANEW£131USED£66DEMANDEstablishedAnalysed 6 Nov 20268Silent Hill 4: The RoomHorror48North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£131USED£62DEMANDNicheAnalysed 9 Aug 20269Urban Chaos Riot ResponseFPS42North America (NTSC-U)MID-ALPHANEW£120USED£37DEMANDNicheAnalysed 14 Oct 202610Halo: Combat Evolved2001 · FPS38UK / PALMID-ALPHANEW£120USED£3DEMANDEstablishedAnalysed 9 Jun 2026

Rising

£$€

Market movement “Strengthening” or “Emerging” — collector interest heading up.

1Shenmue IIAction & Adventure55North America (NTSC-U)HIGH-ALPHANEW£29USED£11DEMANDEmergingAnalysed 23 Oct 20262Metal Slug 3Action & Adventure52UK / PALHIGH-ALPHANEW£21USED£15DEMANDNicheAnalysed 26 Jun 2026

How this list is made: every entry is a Xbox game MyPlayersVault has analysed. Prices are the new and used values shown on each game’s page, for the region named on the card. Collector context, not financial advice.